Home › New York › Shelter Island Heights

Beach Wedding Venues near Shelter Island Heights, NY

Shelter Island Heights has 3 beach wedding venues nearby — including 1 with a private beach and 3 with on-site lodging. Each one is verified within a few miles of a real shoreline, and listings are ranked by what couples say (rating weighted by review count), with the distance to the water, ocean-view and private-beach flags, and what's included — so you can shortlist your tours and go see them in person.

Sunset Beach Hotel

4.1 ★★★★☆ 559 reviews

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY

On-site lodging breathtaking beach settingstaff who go above & beyond

Sleek rooms with decks & sea views in a modern hotel featuring a lively French bistro/bar.

The Ram's Head Inn

4.4 ★★★★☆ 239 reviews

108 S Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY

Private beach On-site lodging breathtaking beach settingstaff who go above & beyond

Unassuming rooms in a historic island inn with an elegant restaurant, a bar & a private beach.

Shelter Island House

4.5 ★★★★★ 72 reviews

11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY

On-site lodging breathtaking beach settingstaff who go above & beyond

Quaint country inn offering casual-chic rooms with WiFi, plus an outdoor lounge, a bakery & a pool.

Good to know around Shelter Island Heights

Want a private stretch of sand — no permit, no onlookers? The Ram's Head Inn offers a private beach — evidence from the venue's own site or couples' reviews. Confirm the details when you tour.

Want to stay where you celebrate?

These venues offer on-site lodging — rooms, suites, or a beach house steps from the sand, sometimes the whole property for the weekend. A built-in room block for out-of-town guests, no shuttle at last call, and breakfast on the water the morning after.

Beach venues with on-site lodging, nationwide →

More planning links

Beach venues near other towns